Teaching and Learning Forum 2009 [ Home Page ] [ Contents - All presentations ]

Teaching and learning for global graduates

Welcome



    Teaching and Learning Forum 2009 Home Page
Welcome to the 2009 Teaching and Learning Forum!

This year's theme focuses on preparing for global graduates and the implications for teaching and learning. We trust that this year's keynotes, papers and presentations will be thought-provoking and inspiring, and conference delegates will leave with ideas and practical tips for enhancing their own teaching and for research into learning and teaching practices.

Table 1 presents TL Forum's standard summary of numbers of submissions and outcomes. As we now have five years of data accumulated under the current review criteria (namely two categories of Refereed paper publication, Research and Professional practice), it is timely to ask whether we can discern any interesting trends. Table 2 is an attempt at an 'overview'.

Table 1: Summary of TL Forum 2009 numbers of submissions and outcomes

Category (a)Submitted (b)AcceptedRejectedOfferedWithdrawn(b)Net outcome(b)
Ref research27819(c)808
Ref prof prac1459(d)8(e)17
Abstract only6867190(f)1179
Workshop550505
  1. See http://otl.curtin.edu.au/tlf2009/criteria.html for definitions of the categories of submissions. Refereed papers, both categories, and all abstracts are published online at the TL Forum Proceedings website, http://otl.curtin.edu.au/tlf/tlf2009/contents-all.html
  2. As there may be additional withdrawals after the date of last revision of this table (21 Jan 2009), numbers in these columns are subject to change.
  3. Of the 19, 3 were offered Professional practice publication, 15 were offered Abstract only publication, and 1 was rejected. Of the 18 offered Abstract only publication, 6 withdrew.
  4. Of the 9, 8 were offered Abstract only publication (1 withdrew), and 1 was rejected.
  5. Added 3 from Research rejects.
  6. Added 15 from Research rejects and 8 from Professional practice rejects.
For TL Forum 2005, 2006, 2007 and 2008 numbers of submissions and outcomes, see similar tables in the 2005, 2006, 2007 and 2008 'Welcome' pages at http://otl.curtin.edu.au/tlf/. Compiler: Roger Atkinson.

Table 2: TL Forums 2005-2009 submissions and outcomes summary (a)

YearResearchProfessional practiceAbs only
submitted
Total all
subs(c)
Total
offers
Submitted AcceptedOffer PPSubmittedAcceptedTotal(b)
20092783145868114111
200820103758599290
20071810412812377368
2006311271361362112103
200518121171516548986
5-yr
average
22.8
(24% of
all subs)
10.4
(46%
accept)
3.6
(16% of
Res subs)
12.6
(13% of
all subs)
7.8
(62%
accept)
11.256.0
(58% of
all subs)
96.091.6
  1. Data sources: http://otl.curtin.edu.au/tlf/tlf2009/editorial.html, http://otl.curtin.edu.au/tlf/tlf2008/editorial.html, http://otl.curtin.edu.au/tlf/tlf2007/editorial.html, http://otl.curtin.edu.au/tlf/tlf2006/editorial.html, http://otl.curtin.edu.au/tlf/tlf2005/editorial.html
  2. Offers total for PP, which includes submissions in the Research category that were offered publication in PP.
  3. This includes all categories: Research, Professional practice, Abstract only publication and Workshops (workshop submission numbers were in the range 0 to 6, with 5-year average being 4.6; acceptances averaged 3.6 per year). Compiler: Roger Atkinson

Table 2 shows that TL Forum's review process receives more submissions in the Research category (about 65%, 5-year average) compared with Professional practice (about 35%). Acceptance rates (5-year average) tend to be higher for Professional practice (about 61%) compared with Research (about 45%). As about 16% of submissions in Research are offered publication in Professional practice, the average numbers published per year in the two categories are similar (columns 3 and 7). Whilst there is considerable variation in each year's number of submissions in all categories (column 9), the acceptance rate summed over all categories (column 10) is consistently high, notwithstanding relatively low acceptance rates for the Refereed paper categories, especially Research. This reflects TL Forum's tendency to make liberal offerings of the Abstract only publication category to authors who were not accepted for Refereed publication. Although only 59% of submissions are for Abstract only publication (column 8), 73% of total offers (column 10) are in this category. This tendency, applied consistently over the years and well-supported by authors, is in accord with our desire to project TL Forum as "a popular avenue for presenting, discussing and 'working up' research and professional practice topics in university teaching and learning, in contrast to being an avenue for the final publication of completed projects." (TLF, 2008).

We express the hope that TL Forum presentations, in all categories of publication, will encourage and help authors to continue developing their research and professional practice topics for future publication in a journal, a book chapter or a conference proceedings. If going in this direction, we recommend that you include an Acknowledgement paragraph in your paper, stating that an earlier (or summary, or preliminary, etc) version of it was presented at Teaching and Learning Forum, and give the URL for your abstract or full paper. Generally, most editors will note with approval that your paper has been 'worked up' and 'tested' in a peer group environment (though they should delete such a paragraph before sending the paper out for double blind review!). In the increasingly competitive matter of getting your research into a Tier A* or Tier A journal (ARC, 2008), 'working up' through a conference presentation may be especially worthwhile.

As we prepare for the 2009 academic year, we wish all colleagues best wishes for a fruitful and stimulating Forum.

References

ARC (Australian Research Council). Tiers for the Australian Ranking of Journals. [verified 13 Jan 2008] http://www.arc.gov.au/era/tiers_ranking.htm

TLF (Teaching and Learning Forum) (2008). TL Forum 2008: Proceedings - Welcome and Editorial. http://otl.curtin.edu.au/tlf/tlf2008/editorial.html

Please cite as: TL Forum (2009). Welcome. In Teaching and learning for global graduates. Proceedings of the 18th Annual Teaching Learning Forum, 29-30 January 2009. Perth: Curtin University of Technology. http://otl.curtin.edu.au/tlf/tlf2009/editorial.html

© 2009 Curtin University of Technology. Copyrights in the individual articles in the Proceedings reside with the authors as noted in each article's footer lines.


[ Contents - All presentations ] [ Refereed papers ] [ Home Page ]
This URL: http://otl.curtin.edu.au/tlf/tlf2009/editorial.html
Created 26 Jan 2009. Last revision: 26 Jan 2009.